Words Dept.: entry

The author published this entry on Thursday 11 September, 2008 at 8:51 pm. It's been filed in the blogging + food + journalism + prcategory

Food critic asks reader’s opinion for a change

Jay Rayner, the Observer food critic, is researching a feature on genetically modified food. The reason I know this is that he’s written a post on the Guardian’s Word of Mouth blog asking for pointers. It’s the first time I’ve heard of a national newspaper doing such a thing. Rayner describes it as “a different approach”.

This initially struck me as a cheeky way of getting a bunch of unpaid minions to do a highly paid celebrity journalist’s work for him. Then I thought the joke might be on him, because it’s surely more trouble than it’s worth.

The art of journalism is, of course, as much about what you leave out of a story as what you put in. By inviting the web and her grandmother to bombard you with opinions and links to background material, how do you find time to get round to writing the feature? As well as worthy amateurs, you’ve got academics, lobby groups, PR firms and others, who are presumably under no obligation to declare an interest in what they are pushing your way.

I get bogged down by dozens of time-consuming calls and e-mails from PR people when I ask for contributions for a feature about, say, the Manchester office market. This is a narrow and – despite my best efforts – inherently dull subject matter of interest to virtually no-one. I do hope Rayner has a team of interns to sift through the mountain of drivel that’s headed his way – there are 126 comments already, although, in fairness, most of them seem to be quite helpful.

The other problem in this approach is that your source material is on view to all. If you leave something out of the finished article either deliberately or by mistake, you lay yourself open to allegations of ignorance, malice or possibly both. And people who post on the Guardian’s blogs can be a savage bunch.

Perhaps I’m being a bit “old media”/Andrew Keen-ish about all this and the Observer should be applauded for opening up the process of researching and writing an article on an important subject. Why shouldn’t “amateurs” be invited to contribute before a feature is published? It might actually make the journalist’s job more pleasant, since, as Rayner observes, what usually happens is:

The piece is written, posted to the web and then the debate begins, sometimes rancorously. Despite – or perhaps because – they are being introduced to both arguments and sources of information that they missed, the journalist, understandably, becomes defensive. The posters become increasingly adamant.

Like GM food itself, the Observer’s approach is essentially a new and unusual experiment with the potential to go horribly wrong. Let’s hope it doesn’t, for the sake of all mankind.

The Conversation {1 comments}

  1. Robin 12 September, 08 @ 10:24 am

    The road to hell eh? I do get the feeling that there are going to be a lot of these kinds of experiments that go completely tits-up at a very early stage. You can see in a lot of websites, many well-known and respected, badly thought-out Web 2 experiments that don’t quite work.

    Everyone’s aware that there something they probably should be pursuing in the digital age, I’m not sure all of them have a great grasp of exactly what it is.

    Reader comments, for example, have to be just about the worst thing that ever happened to the internet. Anyone who posts a reader comment is either stupid, utterly objectionable or sarcastic. Are any of them – at all – any good?

    I’ll leave you to muse on the irony of this statement.

Leave Your Own Comment

You can follow any responses to this entry via its RSS comments feed. You can also leave a trackback if you want.

If you're looking for something specific then give the search form below a try:

RSS Wordpress Grady (theme) Return to the Top ↑

Taking viagra
Where to buy viagra
What is generic viagra
Viagra soft tab
Phentermine no rx
Free sample viagra
Doxycycline chemical formula
Cialis doseage
Indian cialis canada
Levitra sex pill
Cheap brand cialis
Valium side effects
Ubat kuat cialis
Viagra jokes
Xanax identification
Valium online pharmacy
Buy adipex online no prescription
Cialis online order
Discount levitra pharmacy purchase
Brand name cialis overnight
Cialis reviews
How to use clomid
Cialis 10 mg
Doxycycline 100 mg
Mexico viagra
Levitra drug
Tramadol pharmacy
Buy generic viagra online
Generic overnight viagra
Doxycycline hyc
Best price generic viagra cialis
Levitra cheap fast
Viagra price australia
Buy propecia online pharmacy
Buy mg propecia
Buy xanax usa pharmacy overnight
Clomid twins
Drug stores that sell xanax
Phentermine 37.5 lowest price no rx
Online prescription viagra
Clomid and twins
Viagra and penis expansion
Mail order uk viagra
Ativan withdrawal addiction
Viagra side effects women
What is ativan
Phentermine 37.5 mg without prescription
20mg cialis
Viagra pills cheap
Cialis uk online
Celexa 20 mg
Adipex dangers
Canadian levitra
35.7 phentermine
Prednisone not stopping itching
Cheap herbal viagra
Absorption of rectal valium
Prednisone dosing
Viagra cheap mexican
Viagra pfizer online
Viagra rx in canada
Levitra online no prescription
Xanax extended release generic
Xanax no prescription
Clomid ovulation signs
Propecia results
Why is tramadol prescribed
Buy viagra online inu
No prescription adipex
Discount prescription viagra
Prednisone psychosis
Canine prednisone
Xanax bars
Get propecia prescription
Free samples of viagra
Cialis prices uk
Cialis injury attorney columbus
Drug interaction percocet valium
Generic viagra in united state
New medicate natio pills
Birth control pills and xanax
Order cheap propecia
Phentermine obesity
Seduced amanda and viagra
Xanax street value
Can men take clomid
Viagra jelly
Are xanax bars illegal
Xanax 10mg
How adipex works
Viagra spray
Buy cheap levitra online
Free cialis trial
Vill pills
Cheap prescription levitra
Buying soma online without prescription
Lowest price propecia best
Buy xanax without prescription
Order propecia prescriptions
Buy prescription levitra
Purchasing cialis
Xanax dosages
Negative side effects of phentermine
Buy generic cialis overnight
Can take viagra woman
Order viagra without prescription
Viagra drugs
Want to buy viagra
Cheap uk viagra
Compare prices for cialis
Libido pills
Phentermine without doctor approval
Phentermine dangerous
Tramadol shipped cod
Woman viagra
Generic viagra cheap
How does prednisone help with cushings
Buy online order viagra
Cheapest price generic viagra
Discount price viagra
Discount pfizer viagra
Viagra games
Tramadol money order
Cheap phentermine no prescription needed
Viagra cialis compare
Cheapest generic viagra in canada
Is generic cialis safe
Cost of viagra
Viagra like pills
Xanax ingredients
Online order prescription viagra
Generic cialis experiences
Soma no prescription
Discount online propecia
Phentermine pill online discount
Online viagra generic
Generic information viagra
Canadian levitra pharmacy
Viagra buy
Phentermine online prescription
Prednisone danger
Where to buy propecia
Generic propecia india
Viagra through canada
Cialis in canada
Levitra from canadian pharmacy
Viagra side affects
Medicine online viagra
Discount drug prescription viagra
Flouride celexa
Cheapest generic viagra
Cialis levitra viagra vs
Free viagra samples uk
Cialis order online
Phentermine very cheap
Prednisone side effects
Cialis tablets for sale
Levitra online pharmacy
Levitra dosing
Tramadol c o d
Weight loss escondido ca phentermine
Viagra profesional
Cialis from mexico
Buy adipex
Xanax and sexuality
Levitra cheap canadian pharmacy
Generic adipex
Buy cheap levitra
Cialis headaches
Buy cheap viagra pfizer
Viagra toronto
Cheap prescription viagra
Generic viagra samples
Viagra substitutes
Viagra 25mg
Soft gel viagra tablets
Tramadol next day
Cialis sample
Viagra cheapest
Viagra rx
Viagra without prescripiption
Generic cialis europe
Cheap viagra for sale
Viagra buy online in stock
Non prescription viagra online
No rx phentermine
Best deal viagra
Viagra tablete
Uk alternative viagra
Where to buy levitra
Phentermine ingredient
Order adipex
Uk online pharmacies for viagra etc
Viagra buy in uk online
Get cialis
Levitra price
Where can i get viagra
Phentermine urinary metabolites
Does viagra help endurance runners
Viagra generic sale
Phentermine 37.5 mg with no prescription
Levitra where to buy
Connecticut accutane lawyers
Cheap cialis australia
Cialis pharmacy
Tramadol medicine
From generic india viagra
Buy cheap viagra uk
Diet levitra
Women viagra
Buy generic cialis overnight delivery
Mail order viagra in uk
Cialis drug generic
Women taking viagra
Drug hair loss propecia
Female viagra cream
Is adipex safe
Discount propecia propecia
Tramadol no prescription needed
Purchase viagra on line
Viagra sample
Prices levitra
Effexor and tramadol
Buy cheap generic levitra online
Cialis for sale uk
Long term side effects of xanax
Generic viagra review
Acting drunk on ativan
Buying viagra online
Best price on generic viagra
Best price for levitra
Prednisone
Phentermine 37.5 mg no prescription
Viagra from usa
Viagra on line canada
How to buy viagra online without prescription
Cheap cialis no prescription
Valium prices
Viagra american
Cheap prescription cialis
Levitra canada prescription
Adipex without a prescription
No prescription phentermine
Phentermine us pharmacy no prescription
U.k viagra sales
Prednisone 20 mg oral
Buying viagra in uk
Xanax half life
Xanax and weight gain
Viagra next day